Hello, darling readers, today’s post is part of the Nuts in May Blogathon hosted by Movie Movie Blog Blog, a fantastic event dedicated to the comedy of Laurel and Hardy. I love Laurel and Hardy, so naturally, I had to sign up!
Today, I share one of my favorite films of all times, Liberty which stars Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy. On top of being brilliant comedians, they were also excellent actors. And what makes Laurel and Hardy truly unique as comedy team is the genuine affection they have for one another, despite their ever-mounting frustration, they bicker like siblings, you know they will always support one another, no matter what.
It is this unique blend of affection that inspired Samuel Beckett’s classic play Waiting for Godot and Laurel and Hardy often influence the play’s production design.
I realize that many people consider silent films an acquired taste, but when people say they don’t like silent films, I say, “Watch Liberty,” because Liberty is awesome!
Our film opens with an overly stiff and stale salute to liberty, but don’t let this opening stop you, just sit through it, and buckle up, and get ready for the funniest silent film of all time.
Stanley and Oliver are in yet “another fine mess,” this time they have broken out of prison! Their gang shows up in a getaway car, and they bring a change of clothing, and the trouble begins.
In the rushed change, they accidentally trade pants.
At this point, they are dropped off from the getaway car and are on the run, when they notice they are wearing the wrongs pants. Stanley’s pants are ten sizes too big, and Ollie’s are ten sizes too small.
They decide to exchange pants, but where to go?
What follows is a hysterical sequence of increasing humiliation as the two men try to swap pants in the backs of alleys, and hidden behind corners… Even a fish market, where Stanley accidentally picks up a crab in his trousers!
Now imagine, being on the run, trying to look inconspicuous and a crab pinches you. When you are on the run, fresh out of prison, the last thing you want is police attention. And the crab pinches Stanley again, and again and again!
The first thing anyone is going to want to do is to get those pants off, right? Back to square one, where does one take off one’s pants in the middle of downtown Los Angeles?
Finally, they find the perfect spot for the exchange, an elevator on a construction site.
And this is where Liberty transforms from amusing to horrifying, and we find Stanley, Oliver, and the very “pinchy” crab, together on a scaffolding, on top of a skyscraper.
And in case you imagine that the shot above is some studio effect, it is not! Laurel and Hardy are on the roof of the Western Costume Building located at 939 South Broadway in downtown Los Angeles; the scaffolding is an actual three-story high set on the roof of that 150-foot building!
OH. MY. GOD!
What makes this scene even more terrifying is knowing that, like myself, poor Stan Laurel was afraid of heights. According to the Laurel and Hardy Museum blog, Stan began having a panic attack while shooting the scene. I totally understand I have panic attacks just watching the scene.
According to Wes Gehringer’s book Laurel & Hardy: Bio-bibliography:
“During the skyscraper production of Liberty (1929), Hardy attempted to relieve the high-rise anxiety of Laurel by demonstrating the effectiveness of the safety platform some fifteen-twenty feet below their scaffold set. He jumped down to the platform– which he crashed through, falling an additional twenty feet to the ground. Somehow he escaped serious injury. Though the film was eventually finished, Hardy’s good deed could not have been much comfort to Laurel,” (Gehringer 230).

Seriously, how do you not have a panic attack?
The stomach dropping stunts from ladders to beams, elevate our heroes to abject terror as they struggle with a fear of heights, a frightening landscape, and a less than friendly crab, oh yes, and evading the police.
So if you are going to watch only one silent film in your lifetime, please promise me, dear readers you will watch Liberty.
My understanding is there will be prizes, including my favorite Laurel and Hardy dolls! Good luck to all my fellow bloggers, and thanks to Steve from Movie Movie Blog Blog for hosting this event!
Ciao for now, dearies!
Works Consulted
Bible, Karie, Marc Wanamaker, and Harry Medved. Location filming in Los Angeles. Charleston, SC: Arcadia Pub., 2010. Print.
Gehring, Wes D. Laurel & Hardy: A Bio-bibliography. New York: Greenwood, 1990. Print.
Laurel & Hardy’s 1929 Movie “Liberty” Filming Location In Downtown Los Angeles. Dir. Clyde Beck. Youtube, 2016. Web.
“Laurel and Hardy Museum and Online Store.” Laurel Hardy Museum. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 Apr. 2017.
Liberty. Dir. Leo McCarey. Perf. Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy. Hal Roach Studios, 1929. Web.
Pingback: Announcing NUTS IN MAY: A LAUREL & HARDY BLOGATHON (WITH PRIZES!) |
Yes! Liberty is indeed “awesome”. The laughs and the thrills from my first viewing in my youth, to today put Liberty on the top of my list of favourite comedy pictures.
You provided wonderful information along with your affectionate review. Silent fans or not (and it shouldn’t make any difference!), fans of laughter will be clamoring to watch Liberty!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Patricia! Thank you for your kind comment! Indeed, Liberty is truly a gem!
-Summer 🦄😉
LikeLike
Welcome back, just reading this post put a smile on my face!
I have extremely fond memories of watching this amazing short with my grandfather, that skyscraper sequence was simply masterful!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hey Paul! I am glad this post made you smile, L&H comedies always bring back happy childhood memories for me as well.
Thanks for your lovely welcome, too!
-Summer
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was worth the entire review just to get that line, “I had a panic attack just watching the movie!” You definitely caught the spirit of the movie. Thanks for contributing to the blogathon — I’ll let everyone know about the prizes shortly!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, so much!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: NUTS IN MAY: A LAUREL & HARDY BLOGATHON (WITH PRIZES!) is here! |
That height does look daunting even in the pictures – I felt the same when I watched The Walk movie for your Circus blogathon – now made a mental note not to make it a double bill with this x
LikeLiked by 1 person
The horror! Make sure you don’t top it off it with Vertigo or High Anxiety! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the tip, even felt queasy watching Gravity at the cinema xx My stepdudes think its funny as I even get it with Minecraft x
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: The winners of NUTS IN MAY: A LAUREL & HARDY BLOGATHON (WITH PRIZES!) |
Pingback: Second-place winner in NUTS IN MAY: A LAUREL & HARDY BLOGATHON (WITH PRIZES!) |
I absolutely love Liberty. Stan Laurel and the pincher happy crab. I laugh every time I watch it.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I agree, that crab is hysterical! Thanks for dropping by and commenting, Wayne!
Ciao for now,
Summer
LikeLike
Great post! I invite you to add it to this week’s The Classic Movie Marathon Link Party. http://classicmovietreasures.com/the-classic-movie-marathon-link-party-6/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Elaine, thanks! I will check it out!
-Summer
LikeLiked by 1 person