This post is part of the Bette Davis Blogathon which runs April 3-5 hosted by Crystal from In the Good Old Days of Classic Hollywood!
I love classic film characters, the people were glamorous and with razor-sharp wit and no film captures old Hollywood’s witty snark more than the 1942 film, The Man Who Came to Dinner which stars the one and only Miss Bette Davis.
Already a smash Broadway hit by Kaufman and Hart, The Man Who Came to Dinner was a sure-fire comic hit for Warner Brothers.
A Far From Humble Beginning
George S. Kaufman & Moss Hart or “The Gilbert & Sullivan of the 1930s”, produced scripts from 1930-1940 before separating to produce individual projects but the two remained the best of friends. As a duo, their plays include:
- 1930: Once in a Lifetime
- 1934: Merrily We Roll Along
- 1936: You Can’t Take it With You (Pulitzer Prize Winner)
- 1937: I’d Rather Be Right
- 1938: The Fabulous Invalid
- 1939: The Man Who Came to Dinner
- 1940: George Washington Slept Here
The stage version of The Man Who Came to Dinner opened at the Music Box Theatre in New York City October 19, 1939, and closed July 12, 1941. The Man Who Came to Dinner ran for 739 Performances. It was the fourth longest running play of the 1930’s. The film opened in New York at the Strand on January 1, 1942.
Story’s Origin
Theater Critic for the New York Times and the host of the Radio Show The Town Crier, and member of the Algonquin Round Table, Alexander Woollcott was the inspiration for the character “Sheridan Whiteside.”
One day, Alexander Woollcott showed up unannounced at Hart’s estate, and proceeded to take over the house. Woollcott insisted on sleeping in the master bedroom, terrorized Hart’s staff, demanded chocolate milkshakes and chocolate cake, upon departure Woollcott wrote in Hart’s guest book, “This is to certify that I had one of the most unpleasant times I ever spent.” Hart related the story to Kaufman and remarked that he was lucky that Woollcott hadn’t broken his leg and become stuck there. Kaufman looked at Hart, and the idea was born.
Take a Seat at the Algonquin Round Table
The Man Who Came to Dinner‘s larger than life characters are based on the writers and theater elite who met regularly at the Algonquin Hotel during the 1920s. This amazingly creative and silver-tongued group were the subject of the 1994 film Mrs. Parker and The Vicious Circle. The Man Who Came to Dinner allowed audience members a glimpse into the larger than life and glamorous world of the New York Artistic Elite.
Assemble the Players
Monty Woolley originated “Sherry” on Broadway, however, Warner Brothers intended the film as a project for Lionel Barrymore. According to Kevin Hagopian from Penn State University, “there’s some evidence that Barrymore worked on the film, but by then, his alcoholism made it impossible for him to remember the many lines his part required.” And while many classic film fans bemoan the lack of Barrymore’s presence in The Man Who Came to Dinner, I (for once) agree with Bosley Crowther that Woolley was a perfect choice. Lionel Barrymore is a great actor, but I never found him lovable. Monty Woolley as “Sherry” is pure cinematic perfection.
The Warners were most wise when they finally decided to cast Monty Woolley in the title role which he so handsomely played on the stage. For Mr. Woolley makes “The Man Who Came to Dinner” a rare old goat. His zest for rascality is delightful, he spouts alliterations as though he were spitting out orange seeds, and his dynamic dudgeons in a wheelchair are even mightier than those of Lionel Barrymore. A more entertaining buttinsky could hardly be conceived, and a less entertaining one would be murdered on the spot.
-Bosley Crowther, New York Times
Sherry’s clever secretary “Maggie Cutler” is loosely based on author and poet Dorothy Parker.
While Jean Arthur and Myrna Loy were considered to play Maggie, the role eventually went to Bette Davis, Davis “campaigned heavily” for the role (Hagopian, NP).
The remaining cast includes a very catty Ann Sheridan as Hollywood Star “Lorraine Sheldon”. Miss Sheldon is a thinly veiled Gertrude Lawrence. Jimmy Durante plays “Banjo”, Banjo is based on Harpo Marx, and Reginald Gardiner as “Beverly Carlton”, Beverly Carlton is based on playwright Noel Coward. Other notable performances include the on-screen debut of one of my all-time favorite character actors Mary Wickes as the much abused “Nurse Preen” and the bright and charming Billie Burke as “Mrs. Stanley”.
The Plot
The Man Who Came to Dinner is a well-crafted chaotic comedy, based on real celebrities in a fictional situation and reacting with their well-known personalities.
While visiting the Stanley Family on tour, Sheridan Whiteside (a celebrity radio personality) injures hip and is forced to stay at their home for the next six months. Having a celebrity in one’s home is as awful as one would imagine, particularly when that celebrity is Sheridan Whiteside.
Sherry is a demanding and obnoxious guest from hell, whom the family “puts up with” because of his celebrity status and his threat of blackmail and lawsuits. While his famous temper, his weekly radio show, the parade of celebrity guests, and deliveries of live octopuses, impose upon the hospitality of the Stanley family, his faithful secretary Maggie falls for a local reporter, fearing he may lose Maggie, Sherry pulls out all the stops to keep his employee.
The Divine Miss Davis
In The Man Who Came to Dinner, “Maggie Cutler” is the normal one in a world full of over-the-top personalities and she is unlike the typical Bette Davis role. Her performance is understated, yet dynamic. It was in this performance where I first noticed Bette Davis’s true artistry as an actor. It is easy to play a big showy role and draw the audience’s eye, but to play the straight role in a rollicking comedy and still maintain the audience’s attention takes real star power, and Bette Davis has it in spades.
One palm should be handed Bette Davis for accepting the secondary role of the secretary, and another palm should be handed her for playing it so moderately and well.
-Bosley Crowther, New York Times
You can enjoy the trailer here:
Conclusion
Although a contemporary audience member may not recognize the celebrities this film lovingly jabs, the film is well-crafted and stands on its own as a classic comedy. And speaking of funny, I thought I would share a lovely reel of Bette Davis bloopers
Can’t get enough of Bette Davis? Join the party darling, visit Crystal at In the Good Old Days of Classic Hollywood on April 3-5th and check out the full Bette Davis Blogathon!
Ciao for now, Dearies!
Summer
Resources
Crowther, Bosley. “‘ The Man Who Came to Dinner,’ With Monty Woolley, Bette Davis, Arrives in Cinematic Full-Dress at the Strand.” Review. The New York Times 2 Jan. 1942: n. pag. Nytimes.com. Web. 30 Mar. 2016. <http://www.nytimes.com/movie/review?res=9B04E0D91E31E53BBC4A53DFB7668389659EDE>.
Hagopian, Kevin. “Film Notes -The Man Who Came to Dinner.” Film Notes -The Man Who Came to Dinner. New York State Writer’s Institute, n.d. Web. 30 Mar. 2016. <http://www.albany.edu/writers-inst/webpages4/filmnotes/fnf05n11.html>.
“IBDB.com.” The Man Who Came to Dinner. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 Mar. 2016. <http://www.ibdb.com/Show/View/5781>.
“Kaufman and Hart – The Works of Broadway’s Legendary Duo.” BroadwayWorld.com. N.p., 28 Sept. 2014. Web. 30 Mar. 2016. <http://www.broadwayworld.com/article/Kaufman-and-Hart-The-Works-of-Broadways-Legendary-Duo-20140928>.
Reeves, Summer. The Man Who Came to Dinner: Educator’s Resource Pack and Theater Guide.
Jay said:
I love seeing a classic get its due!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Thanks, this film is a true gem! 😉
LikeLike
Pingback: THE BETTE DAVIS BLOGATHON HAS NOW ARRIVED – In The Good Old Days Of Classic Hollywood.
Leticia Magalhães said:
A few months ago I was devastated because this film was chosen for a TCM Party live tweet and I missed it! I really enjoy Monty Woolley in comedy, he is a great forgotten actor. I hope I can catch this film again soon!
Don’t forget to read my contribution to the blogathon! 🙂
Kisses!
Le
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Hey Le!
Oh, I am sorry to hear that, this would have been a fab live tweet film!
I have not been able to find a streaming version and I noticed DVDs of this film are sold at a ridiculous premium ($45-60) but technically still worth every penny.
This film is usually shown during the Christmas season (though it’s not really a Christmas film) so watch for it in December!
You are right Monty Woolley is wonderful, and his “Sheridan Whiteside” is one of the great treasures of classic film. 🙂
Ciao!
Summer
LikeLike
classicemily said:
This is one of those films that’s been on my “to watch” list forever. I enjoyed your backstory on the stage play and film. Can’t wait to see it for myself!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Hi Emily,
The Man Who Came to Dinner is hysterical, I hope you get to see it.
It is often shown during the Christmas season and it is one of the greatest comedies of the 1930s.
Summer
LikeLike
Silver Screenings said:
Ms Davis is divine in this, as you said, and Woolley is the perfect casting choice. (If I were taking over someone estate, I too would be ordering people about for chocolate milkshakes and chocolate cake!)
I didn’t realize Reginald Gardiner’s character was based on Noel Coward – will keep that in mind next time I watch it.
This is a great tribute to a wonderful film. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Can you imagine demanding chocolate milkshakes? What a horrible guest. Cake I can justify a demand for, but demanding milkshakes goes too far ;).
Reginald Gardiner is very Noel Coward in this role, he’s a perfect clever witty Brit, the type that makes me swoon for men like George Sanders and Rex Harrison, in other words VERY Noel Coward. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Silver Screenings said:
Haha – yes, chocolate milkshakes is taking things too far.
Now that I think about it, it’s so obvious that Reginald Gardiner is Noel Coward – and very swoon-worthy indeed!
LikeLiked by 1 person
girlsdofilm said:
Great post Summer! This is a film I’ve watched many times (‘I’m told I’m the only person to do a figure eight from the sitting position!’ is one of my favourite lines!) but reading this I realised how little I knew about the film’s backstory, including the real-life characters that were the inspiration. Look forward to re-watching with that in mind.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Ha-Ha! Yes that is a great line 🙂 love the direct quote, there are so many great lines, I think my favorites are the exchanges between Maggie and Lorraine:
“Lorraine. You know, your hair could be so lovely. I’ve always wanted to get my hands on it.”
“Maggie. I’ve always wanted to get my hands on yours, Lorraine.”
Knowing these characters were based on real people makes this film a lot more fun, and can you imagine all those fantastic people in your social circle?
So much fun!
LikeLike
onestitchatatime said:
I love this film. I don’t know why but reading your review I started imagining Clifton Webb in the part. I think he would have been fabulous but very different from Woolley. Thanks also for the fantastic blooper reel!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Because it is a stage role, many great actors have trod the boards as “Sheridan Whiteside”, I think the important part is to be equal parts irritating and adorable. There is a fantastic stage version with Nathan Lane who plays a different but hysterical Sherry. 🙂
LikeLike
Michaela said:
This film is indeed great. I just love Monty Woolley — a prime example of a part perfectly matching the actor. Bette is marvelous, as usual, but the person who consistently gets laughs from me is Jimmy Durante. Banjo is outrageous and so lovable, like when he helps Maggie get rid of the awful Lorraine. Nice post!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
I LOVE Banjo! I agree one hundred percent! 🙂
LikeLike
In The Good Old Days Of Classic Hollywood said:
Excellent article on one of my favorite Christmas films Summer. As you know I recently seen this on the big screen at my favorite old art deco movie house, and seeing it on the big screen was like seeing it for the first time. It was a packed house full of elderly too, and the laughter was going through the roof. Thanks for joining in on the blogathon.
Oh by the way, I don’t know if you saw my announcement a few weeks ago about my next blogathon, but if you haven’t and if you would like to join in, here is the link.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Hi Crystal, Thanks!
It is events like that that make movie-going truly special, you are very lucky to experience the film the way it was intended for its audience.
We have a similar movie house in Palo Alto, CA there is a guy who plays the Wurlitzer before the shows, seeing classic films there is always a magical experience!
I look forward to reading my way through the Bette Davis event this weekend!
Summer
PS I did see your event and I am very tempted, however, I have been hired to teach this summer, so I want to join, but I might wait till it gets closer to make sure I have the time to commit (between making lesson plans) 🙂
Can’t believe no one has selected Wild and Wonderful with Tony Curtis and Msr. Cognac or the French Tin Tin films!
LikeLike
In The Good Old Days Of Classic Hollywood said:
Hi Summer. Sorry for the late reply. I know what you mean about being busy. I’ve just started studies for an online Freelance Journalism course where I’m going for my Diploma, so I haven’t had that much time to blog. When you do decide let me know.
I’ve also been asked to co-host a blogathon dedicated to Olivia in celebration of her centenary in July, and would love to invite you to join in, if you are free? Here is the link below
LikeLike
sandra said:
The man Maggie falls in love with is such a boring dweeb that my sympathy is entirely with Sherry in his attempt to break up the romance. I think will be back in New York, asking for her job back, within six months.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Hi Sandra!
Ha-ha you are right, poor Bert is a total dweeb! But I guess Maggie had enough of the crazy eccentrics and was in the mood for someone normal! Of course, if I were Maggie it would be all about #teamBeverlyCarlton, because Reginald Gardiner is perfection, wit, and charm!
-Summer
LikeLike
Elizabeth said:
Great piece, it was really fascinating to learn the origin of The Man Who Came to Dinner. I agree that it is an exceptional film and of course Bette Davis is excellent as always! You’ve inspired me to watch it again.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Excellent, getting people excited about classic films is my main objective here! I am glad you enjoyed the post.
Bette Davis is always so cool, but her Maggie Cutler is perfection! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Phyl said:
I first saw this as a play at my college, which was well done. The girl in Sheridan’s role was perfect – she was very theatrical in real life and looked like Gene Tierney. I really enjoyed the movie too – nobody but Monty could play this part and still be likeable. My only wish is that Sheridan would have worn a certain undergarment!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Normally I am a huge advocate for non-traditional casting, but performing without undergarments is JUST PLAIN WRONG on so many levels.
I have my degrees in theater and I can just imagine the tirade my costume design depts would have, starting with shared clothing, basic foundation garments, and hygiene! Cripes.
That said, Monty Woolley is the perfect Sherry!
-Summer 😉
LikeLike
In The Good Old Days Of Classic Hollywood said:
Hey Summer. Hope you’re going well. I just thought I would drop by to let you know that I’ve just announced my Second Annual Barrymore Trilogy Blogathon. And would love to invite you to join in once again. The link is below with more details. I got in early this time
LikeLiked by 1 person
Summer Reeves said:
Hi Crystal, Thanks, I will check it out!
Summer
LikeLike